The Dangers of Hands-free Devices
April 6, 2020

It’s commonly believed that hands-free accessories are a safe way to use cellphones while driving. However, more than 30 studies show that they are actually no safer than handheld devices.

Though hands-free devices are marketed as a way to keep a driver’s hands on the wheel, they present other dangers. For example, many of these devices require a driver to take his or her eyes off of the road—such as to navigate through an infotainment system or to ensure the accuracy of a voice-to-text system. In fact, new studies from the National Safety Council (NSC) show that drivers are more distracted by voice-to-text systems than typing a text message by hand.

Another study, released by the American Automobile Association (AAA), found that even when a driver’s eyes are on the road, the distractions from a hands-free device cause significant impairments. These include, but are not limited to, decreased awareness of surrounding traffic, a sense of tunnel vision and increased reaction time.

Measuring Distracted Driving

In a scientific study on distracted driving, AAA measured how various devices and scenarios impacted a driver’s cognitive awareness. These tasks were then rated based on a scale of 1.0 to 5.0—with 1.0 being comparable to non-distracted driving and 5.0 to an operation span (OSPAN) task (a complex math and verbal question). Here are the study’s findings:

The study also measured how the vocal interface systems of popular smartphone brands impact a driver’s cognitive awareness:

It’s always safest to drive with your mind clear of distractions, eyes focused on what’s in front of you and both hands on the wheel. Contact us today at 800-360-3000 for more resources on safe driving practices and discounts you can receive for being a safe driver.

 

Back to blog

"The Chalmers Group was super friendly, energetic and somehow made me feel happy about purchasing insurance, something I thought I would never say in my life. They were kind, honest, and more than you could wish for while shopping for something as mundane as insurance. Six out of five stars. "
- Jordan P.
"Chalmers was excellent throughout the process. They improved our coverage and ultimately reduced our premium. My agent communicated where there were differences and prepared a nice comparison of coverage. I was happy to place our coverage with Chalmers. "
- Susan A.
"Chalmers was quick to help me with a problem; my agent was knowledgeable and super supportive. I appreciate the professionalism and sense of humor. Overall, it was a wonderful experience. "
- Jan H.
"Chalmers walked me through everything in detail. They were fast to respond, friendly and knowledgeable."
- Sean G.
"My Chalmers agent was very helpful, knowledgeable, and patient with the process. To sum it up, the only thing better than my Chalmers agent would be two of her. "
- Richard S.
"Chalmers made it super simple and I had coverage before my lunch break was over. I was very satisfied. "
- Geoffrey P.
"My Chalmers agent answered all of my questions, explained insurance jargon to me, and was polite and knowledgeable. "
- Jennifer T.
"I appreciate how friendly the Chalmers Group is when I talk to them. They always have a positive attitude. "
- Amanda H.